blob: 8d1e50e51a0f18d865bd90a2f923a6df0c1fb8e1 [file] [log] [blame]
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +02001# Copyright 2019 Mirantis, Inc.
2#
3# Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License"); you may
4# not use this file except in compliance with the License. You may obtain
5# a copy of the License at
6#
7# http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
8#
9# Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
10# distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS, WITHOUT
11# WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied. See the
12# License for the specific language governing permissions and limitations
13# under the License.
14
15import os
16import netaddr
17import yaml
18
19from devops.helpers import helpers
20from devops.helpers.helpers import ssh_client
21from retry import retry
22
23from cached_property import cached_property
24
25from heatclient import client as heatclient
26from heatclient import exc as heat_exceptions
27from heatclient.common import template_utils
28from keystoneauth1.identity import v3 as keystone_v3
29from keystoneauth1 import session as keystone_session
30
31import requests
32from requests.packages.urllib3.exceptions import InsecureRequestWarning
33
34from oslo_config import cfg
35from paramiko.ssh_exception import (
36 AuthenticationException,
37 BadAuthenticationType)
38
39from tcp_tests import settings
40from tcp_tests import settings_oslo
41from tcp_tests.helpers import exceptions
42from tcp_tests import logger
43
44LOG = logger.logger
45
46EXPECTED_STACK_STATUS = "CREATE_COMPLETE"
Dmitry Tyzhnenkoc800aad2019-05-27 18:10:46 +030047BAD_STACK_STATUSES = ["CREATE_FAILED", "DELETE_FAILED"]
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +020048
49# Disable multiple notifications like:
50# "InsecureRequestWarning: Unverified HTTPS request is being made."
51requests.packages.urllib3.disable_warnings(InsecureRequestWarning)
52
53
54class EnvironmentManagerHeat(object):
55 """Class-helper for creating VMs via devops environments"""
56
57 __config = None
58
59 # Do not use self.__heatclient directly! Use properties
60 # for necessary resources with catching HTTPUnauthorized exception
61 __heatclient = None
62
63 def __init__(self, config=None):
64 """Create/connect to the Heat stack with test environment
65
66 :param config: oslo.config object
67 :param config.hardware.heat_version: Heat version
68 :param config.hardware.os_auth_url: OS auth URL to access heat
69 :param config.hardware.os_username: OS username
70 :param config.hardware.os_password: OS password
71 :param config.hardware.os_project_name: OS tenant name
72 """
73 self.__config = config
74
75 if not self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name:
76 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name = settings.ENV_NAME
77
78 self.__init_heatclient()
79
80 try:
81 stack_status = self._current_stack.stack_status
82 if stack_status != EXPECTED_STACK_STATUS:
83 raise exceptions.EnvironmentWrongStatus(
84 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name,
85 EXPECTED_STACK_STATUS,
86 stack_status
87 )
88 LOG.info("Heat stack '{0}' already exists".format(
89 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name))
90 except heat_exceptions.HTTPNotFound:
91 self._create_environment()
92 LOG.info("Heat stack '{0}' created".format(
93 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name))
94
95 self.set_address_pools_config()
96 self.set_dhcp_ranges_config()
97
98 @cached_property
99 def _keystone_session(self):
100 keystone_auth = keystone_v3.Password(
101 auth_url=settings.OS_AUTH_URL,
102 username=settings.OS_USERNAME,
103 password=settings.OS_PASSWORD,
104 project_name=settings.OS_PROJECT_NAME,
Dennis Dmitrievc902ad82019-04-12 13:41:30 +0300105 user_domain_name=settings.OS_USER_DOMAIN_NAME,
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200106 project_domain_name='Default')
107 return keystone_session.Session(auth=keystone_auth, verify=False)
108
109 def __init_heatclient(self):
110 token = self._keystone_session.get_token()
111 endpoint_url = self._keystone_session.get_endpoint(
112 service_type='orchestration', endpoint_type='publicURL')
113 self.__heatclient = heatclient.Client(
114 version=settings.OS_HEAT_VERSION, endpoint=endpoint_url,
115 token=token, insecure=True)
116
117 @property
118 def _current_stack(self):
119 return self.__stacks.get(
120 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name)
121
122 @property
123 def __stacks(self):
124 try:
125 return self.__heatclient.stacks
126 except heat_exceptions.HTTPUnauthorized:
127 LOG.warning("Authorization token outdated, refreshing")
128 self.__init_heatclient()
129 return self.__heatclient.stacks
130
131 @property
132 def __resources(self):
133 try:
134 return self.__heatclient.resources
135 except heat_exceptions.HTTPUnauthorized:
136 LOG.warning("Authorization token outdated, refreshing")
137 self.__init_heatclient()
138 return self.__heatclient.resources
139
Dennis Dmitriev4015adc2019-04-15 18:33:44 +0300140 def __get_stack_parent(self, stack_id, stacks):
141 """Find the parent ID of the specified stack_id in the 'stacks' list"""
142 for stack in stacks:
143 if stack_id == stack.id:
144 if stack.parent:
145 return self.__get_stack_parent(stack.parent, stacks)
146 else:
147 return stack.id
148 raise Exception("stack with ID {} not found!".format(stack_id))
149
150 @property
151 def __nested_resources(self):
152 resources = []
153 stacks = [s for s in self.__stacks.list(show_nested=True)]
154 current_stack_id = self._current_stack.id
155 for stack in stacks:
156 parent_stack_id = self.__get_stack_parent(stack.id, stacks)
157 if parent_stack_id == current_stack_id:
158 # Add resources to list
159 LOG.info("Get resources from stack {0}"
160 .format(stack.stack_name))
161 resources.extend([
162 res for res in self.__resources.list(stack.id)
163 ])
164 LOG.info("Found {0} resources".format(len(resources)))
165 return resources
166
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200167 def _get_resources_by_type(self, resource_type):
168 res = []
Dennis Dmitriev4015adc2019-04-15 18:33:44 +0300169 for item in self.__nested_resources:
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200170 if item.resource_type == resource_type:
171 resource = self.__resources.get(
Dennis Dmitriev4015adc2019-04-15 18:33:44 +0300172 item.stack_name,
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200173 item.resource_name)
174 res.append(resource)
175 return res
176
177 @cached_property
178 def _nodes(self):
179 """Get list of nodenames from heat
180
181 Returns list of dicts.
182 Example:
183 - name: cfg01
184 roles:
185 - salt_master
186 addresses: # Optional. May be an empty dict
187 admin-pool01: p.p.p.202
188 - name: ctl01
189 roles:
190 - salt_minion
191 - openstack_controller
192 - openstack_messaging
193 - openstack_database
194 addresses: {} # Optional. May be an empty dict
195
196 'name': taken from heat template resource's ['name'] parameter
197 'roles': a list taken from resource's ['metadata']['roles'] parameter
198 """
199 address_pools = self._address_pools
200 nodes = []
201 for heat_node in self._get_resources_by_type("OS::Nova::Server"):
202 # addresses will have the following dict structure:
203 # {'admin-pool01': <floating_ip1>,
204 # 'private-pool01': <floating_ip2>,
205 # 'external-pool01': <floating_ip3>
206 # }
207 # , where key is one of roles from OS::Neutron::Subnet,
208 # and value is a floating IP associated to the fixed IP
209 # in this subnet (if exists).
210 # If no floating IPs associated to the server,
211 # then addresses will be an empty list.
212 addresses = {}
213 for network in heat_node.attributes['addresses']:
214 fixed = None
215 floating = None
216 for address in heat_node.attributes['addresses'][network]:
217 addr_type = address['OS-EXT-IPS:type']
218 if addr_type == 'fixed':
219 fixed = address['addr']
220 elif addr_type == 'floating':
221 floating = address['addr']
222 else:
223 LOG.error("Unexpected OS-EXT-IPS:type={0} "
224 "in node '{1}' for network '{2}'"
225 .format(addr_type,
226 heat_node.attributes['name'],
227 network))
Dennis Dmitriev4015adc2019-04-15 18:33:44 +0300228 if fixed is None and floating is None:
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200229 LOG.error("Unable to determine the correct IP address "
230 "in node '{0}' for network '{1}'"
231 .format(heat_node.attributes['name'], network))
232 continue
233 # Check which address pool has the fixed address, and set
234 # the floating address as the access to this address pool.
235 for address_pool in address_pools:
236 pool_net = netaddr.IPNetwork(address_pool['cidr'])
237 if fixed in pool_net:
238 for role in address_pool['roles']:
Dennis Dmitrievc902ad82019-04-12 13:41:30 +0300239 # addresses[role] = floating
240 # Use fixed addresses for SSH access
241 addresses[role] = fixed
Dennis Dmitriev4015adc2019-04-15 18:33:44 +0300242 if 'metadata' not in heat_node.attributes or \
243 'roles' not in heat_node.attributes['metadata']:
244 raise Exception("Node {} doesn't have metadata:roles:[...,...]"
245 .format(heat_node.attributes['name']))
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200246
247 nodes.append({
248 'name': heat_node.attributes['name'],
249 'roles': yaml.load(heat_node.attributes['metadata']['roles']),
250 'addresses': addresses,
251 })
252 return nodes
253
254 @cached_property
255 def _address_pools(self):
256 """Get address pools from subnets OS::Neutron::Subnet
257
258 Returns list of dicts.
259 Example:
260 - roles:
261 - admin-pool01
262 cidr: x.x.x.x/y
263 start: x.x.x.2
264 end: x.x.x.254
265 gateway: x.x.x.1 # or None
266 """
267 pools = []
268 for heat_subnet in self._get_resources_by_type("OS::Neutron::Subnet"):
269 pools.append({
270 'roles': heat_subnet.attributes['tags'],
271 'cidr': heat_subnet.attributes['cidr'],
272 'gateway': heat_subnet.attributes['gateway_ip'],
273 'start': heat_subnet.attributes[
274 'allocation_pools'][0]['start'],
275 'end': heat_subnet.attributes['allocation_pools'][0]['end'],
276 })
277 return pools
278
279 def _get_nodes_by_roles(self, roles=None):
280 nodes = []
281 if roles is None:
282 return self._nodes
283
284 for node in self._nodes:
285 if set(node['roles']).intersection(set(roles)):
286 nodes.append(node)
287 return nodes
288
289 def get_ssh_data(self, roles=None):
290 """Generate ssh config for Underlay
291
292 :param roles: list of strings
293 """
294 if roles is None:
295 raise Exception("No roles specified for the environment!")
296
297 config_ssh = []
298 for d_node in self._get_nodes_by_roles(roles=roles):
299 for pool_name in d_node['addresses']:
300 ssh_data = {
301 'node_name': d_node['name'],
302 'minion_id': d_node['name'],
303 'roles': d_node['roles'],
304 'address_pool': pool_name,
305 'host': d_node['addresses'][pool_name],
306 'login': settings.SSH_NODE_CREDENTIALS['login'],
307 'password': settings.SSH_NODE_CREDENTIALS['password'],
308 'keys': [k['private']
309 for k in self.__config.underlay.ssh_keys]
310 }
311 config_ssh.append(ssh_data)
312 return config_ssh
313
314 def _get_resources_with_wrong_status(self):
315 res = []
Dennis Dmitriev4015adc2019-04-15 18:33:44 +0300316 for item in self.__nested_resources:
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200317 if item.resource_status in BAD_STACK_STATUSES:
318 res.append({
319 'resource_name': item.resource_name,
320 'resource_status': item.resource_status,
321 'resource_status_reason': item.resource_status_reason,
322 'resource_type': item.resource_type
323 })
324 wrong_resources = '\n'.join([
325 "*** Heat stack resource '{0}' ({1}) has wrong status '{2}': {3}"
326 .format(item['resource_name'],
327 item['resource_type'],
328 item['resource_status'],
329 item['resource_status_reason'])
330 for item in res
331 ])
332 return wrong_resources
333
Dmitry Tyzhnenkoc800aad2019-05-27 18:10:46 +0300334 def wait_of_stack_status(self, status, delay=30, tries=60,
335 wait_for_delete=False):
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200336
337 @retry(exceptions.EnvironmentWrongStatus, delay=delay, tries=tries)
338 def wait():
Dmitry Tyzhnenkoc800aad2019-05-27 18:10:46 +0300339 try:
340 st = self._current_stack.stack_status
341 except heat_exceptions.HTTPNotFound as ex:
342 if wait_for_delete is True:
343 return
344 raise ex
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200345 if st == status:
346 return
347 elif st in BAD_STACK_STATUSES:
348 wrong_resources = self._get_resources_with_wrong_status()
349 raise exceptions.EnvironmentBadStatus(
350 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name,
351 status,
352 st,
353 wrong_resources
354 )
355 else:
356 LOG.info("Stack {0} status: {1}".format(
357 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name, st))
358 raise exceptions.EnvironmentWrongStatus(
359 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name,
360 status,
361 st
362 )
363 LOG.info("Waiting for stack '{0}' status <{1}>".format(
364 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name, status))
365 wait()
366
367 def revert_snapshot(self, name):
368 """Revert snapshot by name
369
370 - Revert the heat snapshot in the environment
371 - Try to reload 'config' object from a file 'config_<name>.ini'
372 If the file not found, then pass with defaults.
373 - Set <name> as the current state of the environment after reload
374
375 :param name: string
376 """
377 LOG.info("Reading INI config (without reverting env to snapshot) "
378 "named '{0}'".format(name))
379
380 try:
381 test_config_path = self._get_snapshot_config_name(name)
382 settings_oslo.reload_snapshot_config(self.__config,
383 test_config_path)
384 except cfg.ConfigFilesNotFoundError as conf_err:
385 LOG.error("Config file(s) {0} not found!".format(
386 conf_err.config_files))
387
388 self.__config.hardware.current_snapshot = name
389
390 def create_snapshot(self, name, *args, **kwargs):
391 """Create named snapshot of current env.
392
393 - Create a snapshot for the environment
394 - Save 'config' object to a file 'config_<name>.ini'
395
396 :name: string
397 """
Dennis Dmitrievfa1774a2019-05-28 15:27:44 +0300398 if not settings.MAKE_SNAPSHOT_STAGES:
399 msg = ("[ SKIP snapshot '{0}' because MAKE_SNAPSHOT_STAGES=false ]"
400 .format(name))
401 LOG.info("\n\n{0}\n{1}".format(msg, '*' * len(msg)))
402 return
403
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200404 LOG.info("Store INI config (without env snapshot) named '{0}'"
405 .format(name))
406 self.__config.hardware.current_snapshot = name
407 settings_oslo.save_config(self.__config,
408 name,
409 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name)
410
411 def _get_snapshot_config_name(self, snapshot_name):
412 """Get config name for the environment"""
413 env_name = self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name
414 if env_name is None:
415 env_name = 'config'
416 test_config_path = os.path.join(
417 settings.LOGS_DIR, '{0}_{1}.ini'.format(env_name, snapshot_name))
418 return test_config_path
419
420 def has_snapshot(self, name):
421 # Heat doesn't support live snapshots, so just
422 # check if an INI file was created for this environment,
423 # assuming that the environment has the configuration
424 # described in this INI.
425 return self.has_snapshot_config(name)
426
427 def has_snapshot_config(self, name):
428 test_config_path = self._get_snapshot_config_name(name)
429 return os.path.isfile(test_config_path)
430
431 def start(self, underlay_node_roles, timeout=480):
432 """Start environment"""
433 LOG.warning("HEAT Manager doesn't support start environment feature. "
434 "Waiting for finish the bootstrap process on the nodes "
435 "with accessible SSH")
436
437 check_cloudinit_started = '[ -f /is_cloud_init_started ]'
438 check_cloudinit_finished = ('[ -f /is_cloud_init_finished ] || '
439 '[ -f /var/log/mcp/.bootstrap_done ]')
440 check_cloudinit_failed = 'cat /is_cloud_init_failed'
441 passed = {}
442 for node in self._get_nodes_by_roles(roles=underlay_node_roles):
443
444 try:
445 node_ip = self.node_ip(node)
446 except exceptions.EnvironmentNodeAccessError:
447 LOG.warning("Node {0} doesn't have accessible IP address"
448 ", skipping".format(node['name']))
449 continue
450
451 LOG.info("Waiting for SSH on node '{0}' / {1} ...".format(
452 node['name'], node_ip))
453
454 def _ssh_check(host,
455 port,
456 username=settings.SSH_NODE_CREDENTIALS['login'],
457 password=settings.SSH_NODE_CREDENTIALS['password'],
458 timeout=0):
459 try:
460 ssh = ssh_client.SSHClient(
461 host=host, port=port,
462 auth=ssh_client.SSHAuth(
463 username=username,
464 password=password))
465
466 # If '/is_cloud_init_started' exists, then wait for
467 # the flag /is_cloud_init_finished
468 if ssh.execute(check_cloudinit_started)['exit_code'] == 0:
469 result = ssh.execute(check_cloudinit_failed)
470 if result['exit_code'] == 0:
471 raise exceptions.EnvironmentNodeIsNotStarted(
472 "{0}:{1}".format(host, port),
473 result.stdout_str)
474
475 status = ssh.execute(
476 check_cloudinit_finished)['exit_code'] == 0
477 # Else, just wait for SSH
478 else:
479 status = ssh.execute('echo ok')['exit_code'] == 0
480 return status
481
482 except (AuthenticationException, BadAuthenticationType):
483 return True
484 except Exception:
485 return False
486
487 def _ssh_wait(host,
488 port,
489 username=settings.SSH_NODE_CREDENTIALS['login'],
490 password=settings.SSH_NODE_CREDENTIALS['password'],
491 timeout=0):
492
493 if host in passed and passed[host] >= 2:
494 # host already passed the check
495 return True
496
497 for node in self._get_nodes_by_roles(
498 roles=underlay_node_roles):
499 ip = node_ip
500 if ip not in passed:
501 passed[ip] = 0
502 if _ssh_check(ip, port):
503 passed[ip] += 1
504 else:
505 passed[ip] = 0
506
507 helpers.wait(
508 lambda: _ssh_wait(node_ip, 22),
509 timeout=timeout,
510 timeout_msg="Node '{}' didn't open SSH in {} sec".format(
511 node['name'], timeout
512 )
513 )
514 LOG.info('Heat stack "{0}" ready'
515 .format(self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name))
516
Dmitry Tyzhnenkoc800aad2019-05-27 18:10:46 +0300517 def _verify_resources_status(self, status):
518 """Check that all resources have verified `status`
519
520 In case when all resources have expected status return empty list,
521 otherwise return a list with resources with incorrect status.
522 """
523 ret = [r for r in self.__nested_resources if
524 r.resource_status != status]
525 return ret
526
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200527 def _create_environment(self):
528 tpl_files, template = template_utils.get_template_contents(
529 self.__config.hardware.heat_conf_path)
530 env_files_list = []
531 env_files, env = (
532 template_utils.process_multiple_environments_and_files(
533 env_paths=[self.__config.hardware.heat_env_path],
534 env_list_tracker=env_files_list))
535
536 fields = {
537 'stack_name': self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name,
538 'template': template,
539 'files': dict(list(tpl_files.items()) + list(env_files.items())),
540 'environment': env,
Dennis Dmitrievc902ad82019-04-12 13:41:30 +0300541 'parameters': {
542 'mcp_version': settings.MCP_VERSION,
543 'env_name': settings.ENV_NAME,
544 }
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200545 }
546
547 if env_files_list:
548 fields['environment_files'] = env_files_list
Dmitry Tyzhnenkoc800aad2019-05-27 18:10:46 +0300549
550 @retry(heat_exceptions.HTTPBadGateway, delay=15, tries=20)
551 def safe_heat_stack_create():
552 self.__stacks.create(**fields)
553
554 @retry(exceptions.EnvironmentBadStatus, delay=60, tries=3)
555 def safe_create():
556 self.delete_environment()
557 safe_heat_stack_create()
558 self.wait_of_stack_status(EXPECTED_STACK_STATUS, tries=140)
559 LOG.info("Stack '%s' created",
560 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name)
561 incorrect_resources = self._verify_resources_status(
562 EXPECTED_STACK_STATUS)
563 if incorrect_resources:
564 LOG.info("Recreate the stack because some resources have "
565 "incorrect status")
566 for r in incorrect_resources:
567 LOG.error(
568 'The resource %s has status %s. But it should be %s',
569 r.resource_name,
570 r.resource_status,
571 EXPECTED_STACK_STATUS)
572 st = self._current_stack.stack_status
573 raise exceptions.EnvironmentBadStatus(
574 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name,
575 EXPECTED_STACK_STATUS,
576 st,
577 incorrect_resources)
578 safe_create()
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200579
580 def stop(self):
581 """Stop environment"""
582 LOG.warning("HEAT Manager doesn't support stop environment feature")
583 pass
584
Dmitry Tyzhnenkoc800aad2019-05-27 18:10:46 +0300585 def delete_environment(self):
586 if list(self.__stacks.list(
587 stack_name=self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name)):
588 LOG.info("Delete stack '%s'",
589 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name)
590
591 @retry(heat_exceptions.HTTPBadGateway, delay=15, tries=20)
592 def safe_heat_stack_delete():
593 self.__stacks.delete(self._current_stack.id)
594
595 safe_heat_stack_delete()
596 self.wait_of_stack_status('DELETE_COMPLETE',
597 delay=30, tries=20,
598 wait_for_delete=True)
599 else:
600 LOG.warning("Can't delete stack '%s' due is absent",
601 self.__config.hardware.heat_stack_name)
602
Dennis Dmitrievf5f2e602017-11-03 15:36:19 +0200603# TODO(ddmitriev): add all Environment methods
604 @staticmethod
605 def node_ip(node, address_pool_name='admin-pool01'):
606 """Determine node's IP
607
608 :param node: a dict element from the self._nodes
609 :return: string
610 """
611 if address_pool_name in node['addresses']:
612 addr = node['addresses'][address_pool_name]
613 LOG.debug('{0} IP= {1}'.format(node['name'], addr))
614 return addr
615 else:
616 raise exceptions.EnvironmentNodeAccessError(
617 node['name'],
618 "No addresses available for the subnet {0}"
619 .format(address_pool_name))
620
621 def set_address_pools_config(self):
622 """Store address pools CIDRs in config object"""
623 for ap in self._address_pools:
624 for role in ap['roles']:
625 self.__config.underlay.address_pools[role] = ap['cidr']
626
627 def set_dhcp_ranges_config(self):
628 """Store DHCP ranges in config object"""
629 for ap in self._address_pools:
630 for role in ap['roles']:
631 self.__config.underlay.dhcp_ranges[role] = {
632 "cidr": ap['cidr'],
633 "start": ap['start'],
634 "end": ap['end'],
635 "gateway": ap['gateway'],
636 }
637
638 def wait_for_node_state(self, node_name, state, timeout):
639 raise NotImplementedError()
640
641 def warm_shutdown_nodes(self, underlay, nodes_prefix, timeout=600):
642 raise NotImplementedError()
643
644 def warm_restart_nodes(self, underlay, nodes_prefix, timeout=600):
645 raise NotImplementedError()
646
647 @property
648 def slave_nodes(self):
649 raise NotImplementedError()